Click here to return to IRED.com
Navigation Tabs


Mortgage Lenders Tools for Agents Consumer Services Ratings and Icons Descriptions USA Realty Directory International Realty Directory Add or Enhance a Link in the IRED Directories Advertising on IRED Information about IRED Site Map

Stuart Lieberman
Stuart Lieberman, Esq.
liebermanblecher.com

*NJ Deputy Attorney General assigned to the State Department of Environmental Protection from 1986 - 1990.
*Partner in the environmental law firm of Lieberman & Blecher, P.C. in Princeton, New Jersey
*Lectures for the N.J. Institute for Continuing Legal Education (ICLE), and is available for other speaking engagements through the year.


The Environment
Lieberman Archives
US Environmental Protection Agency


Attitude & News Home

Directories
  Int'l Realty
  US Realty



THE ENVIRONMENT
No Statute of Limitations for Murder Or Pollution
Stuart Lieberman, Esq.,

In many places, there is no statute of limitations for murder. This means that if you murdered someone in 1950 and the police just located you today, you could be tried in 1999 for the crime.

Statutes of limitations are important tools in our judicial system. The idea is that people who have claims against other people should not wait indefinitely to assert them, and should not be able to hold them "over someone's head" forever. When a statute of limitations applies, it means that law suits filed after the statute of limitations period has expired are barred and will not be heard.

Most lawsuits are based on claims that are subject to a statute of limitations. For example, if you want to sue someone over a car accident, a slip and fall, sexual harassment, or a breach of contract, you must do so within the period allowed by law. This is usually a period of several years. It varies, depending on the State in which you live or in which the complained of action took place.

In many States, murder has no statute of limitations. The reason is that murder is such a terrible crime that no one should be allowed to get away with it simply because he or she remained in hiding until an arbitrary period of time elapsed.

Now, there is another kind of lawsuit that has no statute of limitations. In New Jersey, a court has just confirmed that in certain instances environmental pollution claims have no statute of limitations as well.

In Mason v. Mobil Oil, the plaintiffs purchased an abandoned gas station in 1985. In 1990, they contracted to sell the property to a bank. At that time, the plaintiffs learned that their property was contaminated with gasoline.

The plaintiffs elected not to hire an attorney, and on their own filed a lawsuit against the people who sold them the property and their former real estate attorney. Among other things, the plaintiffs wanted the defendants to pay all of the cleanup costs.

After the lawsuit was filed, the plaintiffs hired an attorney who re-drafted the lawsuit. This time, the attorney also sued Mobil Oil, who last operated the property as a gas station.

In New Jersey, the statute of limitations for most lawsuits involving injury to property is six years (it varies, an independent determination must be made for every case). Since the new, amended lawsuit was filed more than six years after the contamination was discovered, Mobil asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit because, Mobil asserted, it was filed after the statute of limitations expired.

The court disagreed. It ruled that the claim that Mobil should pay cleanup costs was not time barred.

The only defenses for environmental claims under the Spill Act are acts or omissions, caused by "war, sabotage, or God." Since the law mentions no statute of limitations defense, the New Jersey Court ruled that there is no statute of limitations for private environmental lawsuits brought under the law.

This means that if someone is legally required to pay for all or a portion of a cleanup of contamination, no statute of limitations will bar your lawsuit in New Jersey. So in New Jersey, pollution and murder are seen in the same light, you cannot hide from the law in either case.

By no means does this suggest that New Jersey pollution victims should wait forever to file a lawsuit to collect cleanup costs. First, even though there is no legal statute of limitations, a court can nevertheless rule that too much time has passed such that it would simply be unfair to allow the lawsuit to go forward. For example, over time documents tend to be lost or destroyed and witnesses tend to become lost or unavailable.

This means that even without a statute of limitations bar, if you have a legal claim, it is generally most prudent to assert it now, rather than to sit on it. In any event, important questions such as these should only be answered with the advice of an attorney.

The information provided in this column is written by Stuart Lieberman,a practicing environmental attorney, and is for general information purposes only. It is not legal advice and should not be used in place of legal advice.

Stuart Lieberman, Esq., and IRED.Com, Inc., will not accept any responsibilty for any reliance on the information in this column or any damages whatsoever resulting from reading this column.


| IRED Home | Search IRED |


© 1995-2008 IRED.Com, Inc
All Rights Reserved